Disciplinary systems in criminal risk prevention models.

Legal News

Six years have passed since the reform of the Penal Code of 2015, in which the characteristics that criminal prevention models should have to mitigate or exempt legal persons from criminal responsibility were specified. Within these criteria provided for in article 31 bis 5 is the establishment of a disciplinary system that punishes non-compliance with the measures established by the model (paragraph 5.º of said article).

The doctrine has not paid much attention to this requirement. Nowadays, it is usual for most criminal prevention models to refer exclusively to the sanctioning system provided for in the applicable collective agreement. The application of criminal prevention models is not limited only to the employees of the legal entity, but also to another series of subjects such as its administrators or its suppliers. In the case of these last two examples, it is clear that the applicable collective agreement is not applicable.

In this sense, I consider that it may be appropriate to identify existing disciplinary systems in the law applicable to each of the relationships other than the employment relationship itself. For the categories reflected, administrators and providers, solutions must be found in commercial and civil law respectively.

In the case of administrators, the reference text is constituted by the Consolidated Text of the Capital Companies Law. Specifically, Title VI of the same provides in different chapters that can be taken into account for the design of the disciplinary system applicable to them. These are chapters II, relating to the dismissal of administrators; the III, on their duties; IV, in relation to their responsibility and, finally, within Chapter VI (specifically Article 251, referring to the challenge of resolutions of the Board of Directors).

In the case of suppliers, it must be taken into account that the disciplinary system that is applicable to them should be considered both in the contract that governs the relationship between the parties, and in the cases that apply, it must be included in the offer carried out by the legal person.

The gradation of the sanctions imposed may be similar, for example, to that established by administrative law, qualifying, from lowest to highest, as minor, serious and very serious. Also determine other degrees that are more in line with the reality of the company.

In short, the design of an adequate disciplinary system that does not collude with other applicable rights is crucial for the criminal prevention model to function at full capacity. This is not a marginal issue, but is another of the conditions that can make the difference between the legal person being exempted from criminal responsibility or being criminally convicted. That is why we consider that it is better not to consider it lightly.

 

 

Manuel Azpeitia

Responsable – Assurance & Compliance

map@uhy-fay.com

 

 

RELATED SERVICES:

*(This article is based on a work published in March 2021, by the autor, in Academia: under the title Una propuesta de estructurar los sistemas disciplinarios de los modelos de Prevención Penal (cfr. artículo 31 bis 5 inciso 5.º)

ACCOUNTANTS AND ESG

ENVIRONMENTAL, SOCIAL AND GOVERNANCE (ESG) Environmental, Social and Governance is taking over from Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) as a way for businesses to demonstrate a measurable commitment to sustainability. ESG covers environmental impact, company culture…

Germany powers ahead in electric cars sales growth

Germany powers ahead in electric cars sales growth – sales more than treble during pandemic Germany has seen the world’s fastest growth in electric car sales of all major economies * during the pandemic, with…

Changes in the Spanish Tax System

  New legislation Law 11/2021, on measures to prevent and fight against tax fraud, published in the official gazette on July 10, introduces numerous changes in the Spanish tax system. Important amendments have been introduced…

Relevant changes affecting Wealth

NEW CHANGES THAT AFFECT WEALTH TAX IN SPAIN Last Saturday 10 July 2021 the Spanish Official Gazette published Law 11/2021 which introduces relevant changes in the Spanish Wealth Tax that may affect you or your…
Menu